Coastal Seafood &
Innovative Cocktails

Join Us For

Happy Hours!

View Happy Hours Menu
4pm - 6pm & 9pm - Close
Mon - Fri

Cocktails

  • Lefty’s Lemonade11
    Hibiscus-infused Tito's Vodka with fresh lemonade.
    Lefty's is honored to partner with RUCK9, a non-profit that provides animals the chance to experience the happiest life they were intended to live. This cocktail is not only delicious but also does good work to support a great cause! When our guests enjoy this philanthropic cocktail, Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar makes a donation to RUCK9, making every sip a step toward helping animals get fitted with their own wheelies.
  • Garden Party13
    Empress Indigo Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, fresh lime juice, cucumber, mint & Prosecco.
  • The Old Rosemary District14
    Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon, Rosemary Ginger Demerara Syrup, Orange Bitters & torched Rosemary.
  • Herb Your Enthusiasm14
    Nolet's Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, Ginger Liqueur, housemade vanilla simple syrup & lime juice.
  • Peach Riesling Mule10
    Deep Eddy Peach Vodka, Riesling, ginger beer & a lime wedge.
  • Island Girl11
    Siesta Key Coconut Rum, banana liqueur & tropical juices. Topped with an orange and a cherry.
  • The Smash12
    Ketel Cucumber Vodka, white cranberry juice, cucumber & lime. Topped with fresh basil.

Tequila

  • Catamaran Margarita15
    Don Julio Blanco, Cointreau, lime and lemon juice's, agave simple syrup & a Grand Marnier floater.
  • Paw-fect Paloma13
    Exotico Blanco, Grapefruit liqueur, lime juice, Grapefruit Soda with a candied grapefruit wheel.
  • Mike's Hot Honey Mango Margarita14
    Casamigos Reposado, mango puree, Mike's Hot Honey, lemon & lime juices, orange bitters & Tajin half rim.

Martinis

  • Prickly Pear14
    Tito's Vodka, Liquid Alchemist Prickly Pear, Cointreau Liqueur & lime juice.
  • Espressotini12
    Borghetti Liqueur, vodka & espresso.
  • Crème Brulee14
    Absolut Vanilla Vodka, Bailey's Irish Cream, housemade vanilla simple syrup, caramel & a caramelized brown sugar top.

Zero Proof

  • Ginger Cooler8
    Ginger Rosemary Demerara, fresh squeezed lime juice & Ginger Beer
  • Island Thyme8
    Once Upon A Coconut, fresh pressed lime juice, pineapple juice, housemade simple syrup & topped with whipped cream
  • Bamboozler8
    Chilled Espresso, housemade vanilla simple syrup & whipped cream
  • Coconut Berry Mojo8
    Coconut Berry Red Bull, fresh squeezed lime juice, mint & Club soda

Wine

Reds, Whites, and Bubbles
Explore our extensive collection of wines, featuring a curated variety of reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling wines. Whether you’re in the mood for a bold cabernet, a crisp chardonnay, a refreshing rosé, or elegant bubbles, we have the perfect pour for every palate.

Beer

Local Breweries
The Watershed Hospitality Concepts family of restaurants is proud to partner with our local craft breweries and we always offer a diverse selection of classic domestic & imported beers.

Rotating Taps
Ask your friendly bartender or server about our extensive list of rotating taps & seasonal craft beer offerings.

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

Lefty's Fresh Oysters

Check out Lefty's Marine Cuisine Board for Our Raw & Seasonal Specialty Offerings

Oyster Shooters

  • Watershed12
    Absolut Tabasco, Bloody Mary Mix & Tajin Rim
  • Traditional8
    Tito's Vodka Shot & Oyster

Pearls & Parm

Baked with Parmesan Breadcrumbs, Garlic Butter, Bacon & Cayenne
  • Half Dozen17
  • Dozen33

Oysters On The Half Shell

House Oysters

  • Half Dozen 13
  • Dozen26

Specialty Oysters

  • Half Dozen MARKET
  • DozenMARKET

LF = Lefty’s Favorites
GF = Can be made Gluten Friendly with substitutions.

From The Steamer

  • Drunken Clams17
    Steamed in white wine garlic broth with celery & onion. Served with crostinis.
  • Snow Crab21
    ½ lb. served with drawn butter
  • Mussels Frites16
    White wine garlic broth with celery & onion. Served with Fries.
  • Thai Mussels18
    Coconut, curry & spices. Served with Fries.

Peel & Eat Shrimp

Tossed with Garlic butter or Old Bay seasoning.
  • 10 ct.15
  • 20 ct.28

Set Sail

  • Key West Conch Fritters16
    Served with housemade remoulade.
  • Seafood Ceviche17
    Voted "Best Local Ceviche"! Our freshest catch marinated in citrus juice & cilantro, with diced peppers & jalapeño.
  • Crispy Calamari17
    Lightly dusted & tossed with banana peppers, garlic butter & spicy marinara.
  • Two Fried Soft Shell Crabs18
    Served with Lefty’s sauce & grilled lemon.
  • Fried Green Tomatoes11
    A classic Southern dish of thick-cut green tomatoes coated in cornmeal & fried until golden. Served with Lefty's housemade Cajun remoulade.
  • Gulf Grouper Bites18
    Lightly fried & served with Lefty's housemade tartar sauce.
  • Louisiana Gator Bites17
    Marinated Gator tail bites, fried crispy & served with housemade remoulade.
  • Big Bad Shrimp15
    Butterflied & panko-breaded, served with housemade cocktail sauce.
  • Smoked Fish Dip12
    Served with saltine crackers.
  • Lefty’s Hush Pups7
    Served with Lefty's housemade hot honey butter.
  • Ahi Tuna Tartare16
    Stacked Ahi Tuna with fresh avocado, tropical salsa & a kick of wasabi & sriracha. Served with tortilla chips.

Harborside Handhelds

Served with your choice of Side. Premium Side +3. GF Bun available +2.                      

  • Soft Shell Crab BLT17
    Lightly fried with bacon, lettuce, tomato & Lefty’s sauce.
  • Gulf Grouper SandwichMARKET
    Prepared grilled, blackened or fried with lettuce, tomato, onion & our housemade tartar sauce.
  • Smash Burger Double Patty16
    Served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle & Lefty’s sauce. ADD: Bacon +2
  • Maine Lobster RollsMARKET
    Premium Maine lobster meat, lightly tossed with celery, onion & mayo then piled into two toasted, buttered split rolls.
  • Tacos
    Two soft, warm flour tortillas topped with shredded cabbage, pico de gallo & cilantro crema. Prepared grilled, blackened or fried.
    With your choice of Protein:
    Gulf Grouper - MARKET | Chicken - 17 | Shrimp - 17 | Mahi - 17 | Ahi Tuna - 22
    Want one more taco? +6

LEFTY'S PO' BOYS

Served on a crispy & soft roll with lettuce, tomato, dill pickle chips & our housemade remoulade sauce.

  • Catfish16
  • Gulf GrouperMARKET
  • Shrimp17

Market Signatures

Right column only served with your choice of two Sides. Premium Side +3.

 

  • Seafood Boil42
    This Lefty’s favorite was added to our menu after its popular debut at The Bay park. Every time you enjoy this dish, Watershed Hospitality Concepts makes a donation to The Bay. Large Snow crab, peel & eat shrimp, mussels, crawdads, andouille, corn & red potatoes. Prepared with a blend of garlic butter, Cajun spices & herbs
  • Seared Sesame Ahi Tuna28
    Ahi tuna topped with ponzu sauce and served with Soba noodles
  • Snow Crab Legs45
    A full pound with corn and red potatoes. Add extra cluster +21
  • Steak Frites32
    10 oz. Skirt Steak with Chimichurri sauce. Served with Fries
  • Fresh CatchMARKET
  • Sea ScallopsMARKET
    Pan seared with white wine, lemon & shallots
  • Gulf GrouperMARKET
    Prepared grilled, blackened or fried
  • Atlantic Salmon30
    Prepared grilled or blackened & served with our housemade Dill crema

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

From The Garden

Seasonal produce from our local organic farm partner, Blumenberry Farms
  • Neptune Salad15
    Our take on the classic Greek. Romaine, red onion, cucumber, Kalamata olives, tomatoes, pepperoncini & feta cheese
  • Lefty’s Caesar Salad13
    Romaine, croutons, parmesan & our housemade Caesar dressing
  • Dog House Salad14
    Romaine, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, mixed cheese, housemade croutons
  • The Wedge13
    Crisp Iceberg lettuce with bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes, red onion, bacon, bleu cheese dressing & drizzled with a balsamic glaze
Add your choice of Protein: Chicken +8 | Shrimp +10 | Salmon +12 | Gulf Grouper +MARKET | Fresh Catch +MARKET | Ahi Tuna +14

CAPTAIN'S KETTLES

  • Seafood ChowderCup | 8     Bowl | 12
    Cream base chock full of Gulf Grouper & clams
  • Red Beans & RiceCup | 6     Bowl | 10
    Dirty rice with red beans, andouille sausage, bell peppers & onions
  • Lefty's GumboCup | 9     Bowl | 13
    Alligator & pork sausage, chicken, dirty rice & okra

Crisp & Crunch

Served with crinkle cut fries & housemade coleslaw.
  • Watershed Platter28
    Shrimp, Bay scallops & North Atlantic white fish served with our housemade tartar sauce
  • Gulf Platter26
    Shrimp, Gator bites & Gulf Grouper bites served with our housemade tartar sauce
  • Fish & Chips23
    Beer Battered North Atlantic white fish served with our housemade tartar sauce
  • Fried Catfish Dinner24
    Cajun cornmeal dusted and served with a coupla hush puppies
  • Crispy Shrimp Platter24
    Panko breaded and fried. Served with housemade cocktail sauce

Galley Grains & Pasta

GF Gluten Friendly pasta available +4
  • Downtown Seafood Pasta35
    Lobster, scallops, shrimp served over linguine with a shallot garlic butter sauce
  • Shrimp & Grits26
    Jumbo Gulf shrimp grilled and paired with creamy Southern grits, peppers & andouille. Make it Sea Scallops & Grits — MARKET
  • Linguine with Clams22
    With garlic, shallots & a white wine butter sauce
  • Cajun Chicken Alfredo19
    Cavatappi pasta, bell peppers, onions & parmesan

Sides 4

  • Creamy Southern Grits
  • Red potatoes
  • Crinkle cut French fries
  • Fried Okra
  • Lefty’s housemade coleslaw
  • Grilled Zucchini & Yellow Squash

Premium Sides 7

  • Seasonal vegetable
  • Parmesan panko-breaded Onion Rings
  • Dog House Salad
  • Lefty’s Caesar Salad

LITTLE MARINERS

12 & UNDER. Served with your choice of Side. Premium Side +2.
  • Fried Shrimp13
  • Fried Chicken Strips11
  • Fried Grouper Fingers12
  • Burger10
    Single patty, American cheese +1
  • Buttered Cavatappi Noodles9
  • Fresh CatchMARKET

SWEETS

Ask your friendly server about our seasonal desserts.
  • Key Lime Pie9
  • Double Layer Chocolate Cake12
  • New York Style Cheesecake12

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

CONSUMER INFORMATION: There is risk associated with consuming raw oysters. If you have chronic illness of the liver, stomach or blood, or have immune disorders, you are at greater risk of serious illness from raw oysters, and should eat oysters fully cooked. If unsure of your risk, consult a physician. If you have any allergies or dietary restrictions, please advise your server before you order. Our fresh fare is prepared in an environment where glutens, dairy and nuts are present. Menu subject to change.

Accessibility by WAH