Coastal Seafood &
Innovative Cocktails

Join Us For

Happy Hours!

View Happy Hours Menu
4pm - 6pm
9pm - Close
Mon - Fri

Signature Cocktails

  • Lefty’s Lemonade10
    Lefty’s is honored to partner with RUCK9, a non-profit that provides animals the chance toexperience the happiest life they were intended to live. Every Lefty’s Lemonade you purchase we donate a portion to RUCK9.
  • Water Lily10
    Three Olives Rose, Cointreau, Fresh Lemon Juice, Crème de Violette
  • Garden Party13
    Empress Indigo Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, fresh lime juice, cucumber, mint & Prosecco
  • Watershed Oyster Shooters12
    Chile Infused Tito's, Bloody Mary Mix & Tajin Rim
  • Traditional Oyster Shooters8
    Tito's Vodka Shot & Oyster

Cocktails

  • Sandia en Fuego11
    ose Cuervo Devil’s Reserve, Luxardo Maraschino Cherry Liqueur, Watermelon, Agave, fresh lime juice & a Tajin rim
  • Salty Dog Spritz12
    Dobel Humito Smoked Tequila, Salted Lime Cordial, Grapefruit juice, Grapefruit Bitters, Prosecco & a Black Salted rim
  • Neptune’s Treasure12
    Dobel Maestro Diamante Tequila, Elderflower Liqueur, Blue Curacao & fresh lime juice
  • The Old Rosemary District14
    Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon, Rosemary Ginger Demerara Syrup, Orange Bitters & torched Rosemary
  • Papa’s Rum Runner11
    Siesta Key Spiced Rum, Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum, housemade cherry simple syrup & tropical juices

Beer

Local Breweries
The Watershed Hospitality Concepts family of restaurants is proud to partner with our local craft breweries and we always offer a diverse selection of classic domestic & imported beers.

Rotating Taps
Ask your friendly bartender or server about our extensive list of rotating taps & seasonal craft beer offerings.

Wine

Reds, Whites, and Bubbles
Explore our extensive collection of wines, featuring a curated variety of reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling wines. Whether you’re in the mood for a bold cabernet, a crisp chardonnay, a refreshing rosé, or elegant bubbles, we have the perfect pour for every palate.

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

Lefty's Fresh Oysters

Check out Lefty's Marine Cuisine Board for Our Raw & Seasonal Specialty Offerings

Oyster Shooters

  • Watershed12
    Spicy chile vodka, Bloody Mary Mix & Tajin Rim
  • Traditional8
    Tito's Vodka Shot & Oyster

Pearls & Parm

Baked with Parmesan Breadcrumbs, Garlic Butter, Bacon & Cayenne
  • Half Dozen16
  • Dozen32

LF = Lefty’s Favorites
GF = Can be made Gluten Friendly with substitutions.

Oysters Raw

  • Half Dozen | DozenMarket

From The Steamer

Simmered in White Wine Garlic Butter Broth & Served with Grilled Crostini
  • Drunken Clams16
    One Dozen Cedar Key Middlenecks
  • Steamed Mussels16
    One Pound Prince Edward Island

Peel & Eat Shrimp

Choose Bare or Tossed with Garlic Butter or Old Bay
  • 10 ct.15
  • 20 ct.28

Set Sail

  • Lobster BitesMarket
    Maine Lobster tail lightly fried and served with our Piña Tropicale sauce
  • Key West Conch Fritters14
    Served with Lefty’s Cajun remoulade
  • Seafood Ceviche15
    Our freshest catch marinated in citrus juice & cilantro
  • Crispy Calamari15
    Served with spicy marinara
  • Frog Legs15
    Lightly fried and served with Lefty’s Tartar sauce
  • Two Fried Soft Shell Crabs16
    Served with Lefty’s sauce & grilled lemon
  • Gulf Grouper Bites16
    Lightly fried & served with Lefty’s tartar sauce
  • Louisiana Gator Tail Bites16
    Tenderized & crispy, served with Lefty’s Cajun remoulade
  • Big Bad Shrimp15
    Butterflied & panko-breaded, served with Lefty’s cocktail sauce
  • Smoked Fish Dip14
    Served with crispy corn tortilla chip
  • Lefty’s Hush Pups6
    Served with hot honey butter

Handhelds

Served with your choice of Side.
GF Bun available +2

  • Soft Shell Crab BLT16
    Lightly fried with bacon, lettuce, tomato & Lefty’s sauce.
  • Gulf Grouper Sandwich25
    Prepared grilled, seared with Cajun seasoning or fried. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion & Lefty’s tartar sauce.
  • Smash Burger Double Patty15
    Served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & Lefty’s sauce.
  • Fried Chicken Thigh Sandwich15
    Skin-on, dark meat house-brined with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle.
  • Big Fish Sandwich18
    Beer-battered Haddock with lettuce, tomato & Lefty’s tartar sauce.
  • Maine Lobster RollMARKET
    Two lobster rolls mixed with celery, onion, tomato & mayo nestled in a toasted, buttered split roll.
  • Seafood Tacos
    Two soft, warm flour tortillas topped with shredded cabbage, pico de gallo & cilantro crema. Prepared grilled, seared with Cajun seasoning or fried. With your choice of Protein:
    Want one more taco? +6
    Gulf Grouper - 24 | Lobster - MARKET | Shrimp - 17 | Mahi - 17

Market Signatures

Served with seasonal vegetables & your choice of Side. Premium Side +2.

Check our Boards for our Chef Specials, Seasonal Fin Fish & Freshly Butchered Meats

  • Fresh CatchMARKET
  • Butcher’s BlockMARKET
  • Gulf Grouper32
    Prepared grilled, seared with Cajun seasoning or fried
  • Crispy Shrimp26
    Butterflied & panko-breaded
  • Sea Scallops32
    Pan seared with white wine, lemon, shallots
  • Salmon24
    Atlantic Salmon prepared grilled or seared with Cajun seasoning & with our housemade Dill sauce

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

From The Garden

Seasonal produce from our local organic farm partner, Blumenberry Farms
  • Neptune Salad13
    Our take on the classic Greek. Romaine,red onion, cucumber, Kalamata olive,tomatoes, pepperoncini, feta cheese
  • Lefty’s Caesar Salad12
    Romaine, fried anchovy, parmesan cheese, Lefty’s housemade croutons
  • Spinach Salad12
    Spinach, mushrooms, bacon, tomato, red onion
  • Dog House Salad10
    Romaine, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, mixed cheese, Lefty’s housemade croutons
Add your choice of Protein: Chicken +6 | Shrimp +9 | Salmon +10 | Gulf Grouper +15

Lefty's Chowders

Cup | 7     Bowl | 10

Lefty’s Chowder – Can’t Decide?
Lefty’s Seafood Chowder and Key West Chowder blended together.
  • Seafood Chowder
    Cream base chock full of Gulf Grouper & clams
  • Key West Chowder
    Tomato base with Key West conch, Gulf Grouper & clams

Crisp & Crunch

Our crispy, golden platters are served with Lefty’s housemade coleslaw & French fries.
  • Watershed Platter26
    Shrimp, Bay scallops, Atlantic Haddock
  • Myakka Platter24
    Frog legs, gator bites & shrimp
  • Fish & Chips20
    Beer battered Atlantic Haddock Served with French fries & Lefty’s housemade coleslaw

Pasta & Grains

GF Gluten Friendly pasta available +4
  • Watershed Seafood Pasta32
    Lobster, scallops, shrimp served over linguine with a shallot garlic butter sauce.
  • Shrimp & Grits26
    Jumbo Gulf shrimp paired with creamy Southern grits & spicy andouille.
  • Linguine with Clams22
    Garlic, shallot, white wine butter sauce
  • Chicken a la Vodka18
    Linguine, spinach, red onion, tossed in a creamy Cajun vodka sauce

Sides 4

  • Creamy Southern Grits
  • Red potatoes
  • French fries
  • Fried Okra
  • Red beans & rice
  • Lefty’s housemade coleslaw

Premium Sides 6

  • Seasonal vegetables
  • Parmesan panko-breaded Onion Rings
  • Dog House Salad
  • Lefty’s Caesar Salad

LITTLE MARINERS 9

Served with your choice of housemade coleslaw, seasonal vegetables or French fries.
  • Fried Shrimp
  • Fried Chicken Strips
  • Fried Grouper Bites
  • Burger
    Single patty, American cheese +1
  • Mac & Cheese

SWEETS 8

Ask your friendly server about our seasonal desserts.
  • Key Lime Pie
  • Seasonal Local Pies

All menu items and prices are subject to change.

Guests using a credit card will be charged a 3% surcharge fee to offset the rising cost of credit card processing fees that we pay when credit cards are used. There is no fee for cash or debit card usage.

CONSUMER INFORMATION: There is risk associated with consuming raw oysters. If you have chronic illness of the liver, stomach or blood, or have immune disorders, you are at greater risk of serious illness from raw oysters, and should eat oysters fully cooked. If unsure of your risk, consult a physician. If you have any allergies or dietary restrictions, please advise your server before you order. Our fresh fare is prepared in an environment where glutens, dairy and nuts are present. Menu subject to change.

Accessibility by WAH